Oh, you are SO not alone. I've always loved Romano more than Italy, for some reason. I do love Italy a lot, and he has just as much capability for depth and character, but Romano just has an undeniable CHARM. (And, I may be crazy for saying this since they're practically identical, but I find Romano more attractive too. |D)

I can just imagine him getting all attached to it, playing with it and naming it Lovino and whatnot... then eating it whole without a second thought. And getting confused at Romano's horrified look.